Forum:So what is now in effect?

Index → General Discussion

AlmightyKingPrawn User 11 October 2022 Reply or edit Report post

I'm confused as to what proposals are now in effect. I'm at least pretty sure that commercial logos, no print logos, and splitting unused are now a thing.

Nova User 11 October 2022 Reply or edit Report post

Right now, it seems that the Editor's Notes are being changed to Legacy.

Camenati User 11 October 2022 Reply or edit Report post

Nicknames are now limited to 5 Company Bumpers Database will be merged with AVID Commercial logos, boot screen logos, and infoboxes are reintroduced Legacy is the new Editor's Note No more print logo articles Country names will be removed from non-US logos (unless they share the same name) CLG Live will be revived The rules and policy pages will be merged In-credit text sections will be exterminated off the site Unused logos will be separated The availability section are now optional for station IDs and cinema logos Image table of contents will be added Images and videos will be tabbed The site rules section will be rewritten to sound less aggressive Above are all the proposals that have been marked as "Pass" in the proposal page.

Shakla User 11 October 2022 Reply or edit Report post

Would hope some of these guidelines are more fleshed out before being fully implemented. A 5 nickname limit doesn't really solve the problem much, seemed to be more consensus to have less or only official ones. And I hope the "Legacy" section is used more selectively and the low-quality/pov/review/blank Editor's Notes are not fully retained.

TheRealMarcel2000 User 11 October 2022 Reply or edit Report post

I don't know how when all the pages were changed, including the Editor's Note parts was replaced by the legacy ones.

Shakla User 11 October 2022 Reply or edit Report post

Thought the one of the points of changing Editor's Note to Legacy was to get rid of the blank "Editor's Note: None" sections. Yet some editors are fully removing them, but others are just swapping "Editor's Note: None" with "Legacy: None". Which looks silly. Think this needs to be hammered out before it goes totally wide scale.

Iheartparamount User 12 October 2022 Reply or edit Report post

I don't mind the Legacy thing, but what if, one logo or ID doesn't have a legacy? and who can contribute to these legacies?

Iheartparamount User 12 October 2022 Reply or edit Report post

and how can we limit the nicknames down to 5?

Shakla User 12 October 2022 Reply or edit Report post

I don't even know where the 5 comes from. Original proposal said 3, there was consensus for this, some said it should be less, some said only official nicknames. This doesn't solve anything. Honestly, there should be a proposal that only official/well-known nicknames be included. Can be done in a trivia or legacy section. 99+% percent of existing nicknames are just made up within the site.

DisneyInternationalFan User 12 October 2022 Reply or edit Report post

Honestly, there should be a proposal that only official/well-known nicknames be included. Can be done in a trivia or legacy section. 99+% percent of existing nicknames are just made up within the site. I agree with your logic, to be honest.