Forum:Another idea...Plastering Mistakes page

From the Audiovisual Identity Database, the motion graphics museum

Revision as of 23:49, 8 November 2023 by JMFabiano (talk | contribs)
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)


avatar
JMFabiano
User
19 October 2023

Reply or edit
Report post



Been watching a few Bad Logo Plaster videos on YouTube, and it gave me an idea for another sub-page on the wiki: Plastering Mistakes. These are audio or visual "variants" caused by plastering mistakes...example: Wigga-Wigga with the Lorimar music. I was thinking of removing them from the general descriptions and putting them in this new section.

Any thoughts?


avatar
Logoarto
Bureaucrat
19 October 2023

Reply or edit
Report post



I don't think they should be removed from the general descriptions, but I think a special page about them could be made, perhaps under the "AVID" namespace.


avatar
Jet Dzhet
User
19 October 2023

Reply or edit
Report post



The page suggestion sounds pretty interesting tbh, as Logoarto said though, I don't really think it's necessary to remove them from the general descriptions.


avatar
TVB
User
19 October 2023

Reply or edit
Report post



In my personal opinion, plastering mistakes shouldn't count as Visual variants, nor Audio variants, especially for sources older than the plastering logo itself. I think plastering mistakes are similar to deterioration versions, as they both aren't from the actual original source, and only a single version of said source. It may not always be like this, but only generally talking about plastering logos. As far as I'm aware, plastering logos have no exceptions, and as such, plastering mistakes aren't exactly audio variations.

Also, like what Logoarto said, maybe there should be a special page about this under the name of AVID.

So there's my personal opinion on the idea. Sort of.


avatar
Flipidk45
User
20 October 2023

Reply or edit
Report post



This sounds like a really good idea to be honest.


avatar
TPatKB
User
20 October 2023

Reply or edit
Report post



It seems like something you would create an RfC for, it's actually a good idea to be honest.


avatar
JMFabiano
User
21 October 2023

Reply or edit
Report post



OK then got a template up:

https://www.avid.wiki/Draft:Infamous_Logo_Plastering_Mistakes?diff=cur


avatar
JMFabiano
User
23 October 2023

Reply or edit
Report post



I saw the "decline" message. Actually I wanted to remove "infamous" to help improve the range of entries. I see someone did it for me. Now is there a chance of it getting approved?

Thanks to whoever did the edit, by the way.


avatar
AUnnamedDragon
User
23 October 2023

Reply or edit
Report post



I saw the "decline" message. Actually I wanted to remove "infamous" to help improve the range of entries. I see someone did it for me. Now is there a chance of it getting approved?
— User:JMFabiano

I don't have any clue right now. Also, I was the one who removed "infamous" from the page.

(I also noticed my post on this thread has broken formatting. I have no idea why.)


avatar
JMFabiano
User
26 October 2023

Reply or edit
Report post



And it's...official?

https://www.avid.wiki/AVID:Logo_Plastering_Mistakes


avatar
TPatKB
User
27 October 2023

Reply or edit
Report post



I can't believe they decided to post the Draft, there are OTHERS to post and the one I posted is still incomplete. It seems they didn't have patience


avatar
JMFabiano
User
8 November 2023

Reply or edit
Report post



Well you can edit the page and add things to it still.

Cookies help us deliver our services. By using our services, you agree to our use of cookies.